Shorefall Sure Fell Short

“All things have a value. Sometimes the value is paid in coin. Other times, it is paid in time and sweat. And finally, sometimes it is paid in blood.

Humanity seems most eager to use this latter currency. And we never note how much of it we’re spending, unless it happens to be our own.”

Robert Jackson Bennett, Foundryside

I received this ARC from NetGalley and Random House in exchange for an honest review.


I was SO excited to get this ARC for two reasons. One, because it would give me a reason to read Foundryside (it had been gathering dust on my bookshelf), and two, the fabulous cover.

Unfortunately, I found Shorefall to be seriously lacking. The digressive plot seemed to scope further backward into the self-referential, while the characters seemed stagnant in this ever-widening world. I could be biased because Foundryside was a chore to read, and thus totally against it from the start. Then again, it’s also because Foundryside’s most redeeming quality was the friendship developing between Sancia and Clef, which was missing in Shorefall.

Where the first book had some interesting world and character building, this one had none. The characters were dull and uninspiring and it made the book near impossible to finish. The magical system so unique and fun but the author described it at SUCH length in this book that I’m thoroughly burnt out on it.

Shorefall is bloated in length and in plot, but will I read the 3rd installment of the Founders Trilogy? Probably. Something in me is hoping for another glimmer of Foundryside.

⅓ of 2020 Behind Us, I’ll Give It 3 Stars

“Humans are strange. They value punishment because they think it means their actions are important—that they are important… it’s vanity.”

-Robert Jackson Bennett, City of Stairs

Considering that it’s ​13 of the way through the year and I am ​13 through my annual reading challenge, I thought I’d give an update. You’d think I’d have all the time in the world and be reading my life away… and I do, but I’m not.

Lately I’ve been slowly chipping away Foundryside, a steampunk sci-fi fantasy by Robert Jackson Bennett (​13 of the way through!). I decided to crack it open after NetGalley and Random House Publishing sent me an advanced reading copy of it’s sequel, Shorefall. Oddly enough, I’ve had a used copy of Foundryside sitting on my bookshelf for months, and I’m glad I did.

Stay tuned for my review – its a little too soon for me to form an opinion yet. What I will say is that, regardless of it previously gathering dust on my shelf, I am very pleased (so far) with Bennett’s world-building and magic system. (And how cool is that cover?)

Working from home has been a challenge in itself so I’ve given myself reading “assignments” to complete as a distraction. Turns out, assignments and deadlines make things a lot less fun! My introverted, book-loving self has found quite a bit of enjoyment in this quarantine. Despite this, I’m really not a deadline person. Being creative in the kitchen, organizing, and watching A LOT of bad TV has filled my spare time.

It’s been hard not to try to distract myself during this weird time. I’m one of the lucky ones. Working from home, healthy, and content with not going anywhere or seeing anyone for weeks on end. Still, I’ve been letting my mind wander freely away from reality. Away from the news, from how much I miss my family, from the lack of socializing. Distractions like reading and writing are helpful and keep my mental health on track.

Why do I make myself feel guilty for not reading my allotted daily chapters? Who knows! Since I’ve been taking it easy in every other way, I’ve decided to do the same for my reading. Books are my passion and my all-around favorite thing and I must find enjoyment in them again before my brain turns into a lumpy potato.

Maybe this week I’ll read another 13 of Foundryside, or maybe not. All I know is that I aim to finish it… eventually. Again, stay tuned for my review and a further update about what I have in store for the next 13 of 2020.